INTERROGATING THE BURDEN OF PROOF IN ELECTION PETITION IN NIGERIA AND TWO OTHER JURISDICTIONS: GHANA AND KENYA

Authors

  • SUNNY MENE PIATE ABIA STATE UNIVERSITY – UTURU

Keywords:

Burden of proof, Common law, Election petition, Non-compliance, Petitioner

Abstract

The paper interrogates the burden of proof in election petition in Nigeria. The objective of the study was to examine the burden or onus of proof required of a petitioner in proving his petition before the electoral tribunal vis-à-vis the ground(s) alleged and relied on by the petitioner for challenging the election/return of the respondent and interrogates same with the position and practice in other jurisdictions particularly Ghana and Kenya. The research method adopted is doctrinal. Findings from the study revealed among other things, that the failure of the electoral process to instill confidence has practically converted the tribunals/courts into another electoral ombudsman. Electoral jurisprudence is founded on the presumption of regularity of election results declared by the electoral umpire which implies that the law takes for granted that a credible election has been conducted which is why election tribunals/courts insist upon that presumption. This tends to lend judicial validity to the view that challenging the outcome of an election through the legal process is a mere formality. The invidious consequence of undue judicial subsidization of the presumed winner of an election and the electoral umpire to the detriment of the petitioner is that legal justice can scarcely redress electoral injustice. Also, the common law rules on the burden of proof apply with same force to election disputes in Nigeria, Ghana and Kenya. The study recommended among other things that while post-election cases should continue to be the exclusive preserve of election tribunals/courts, technical justice must not be allowed to affect the essence of ensuring only people with genuine mandate get the return ticket as winner of the election.

Author Biography

SUNNY MENE PIATE , ABIA STATE UNIVERSITY – UTURU

POSTGRADUATE RESEARCH STUDENT, FACULTY OF LAW, ABIA STATE UNIVERSITY – UTURU

Downloads

Published

2025-01-09

How to Cite

PIATE, S. M. (2025). INTERROGATING THE BURDEN OF PROOF IN ELECTION PETITION IN NIGERIA AND TWO OTHER JURISDICTIONS: GHANA AND KENYA. Journal of Political Discourse, 2(4 (2), 69–79. Retrieved from https://jopd.com.ng/index.php/jopdz/article/view/238